In the face of an object of worldwide hysteria, it's tempting to pick holes and find fault, which I've instinctively done with all the Potter books. Truth be told, Rowling isn't the tidiest writer on the planet, and she could certainly use an editor...but, this is missing the point somewhat...
...she is a remarkable storyteller, completely wrapped up in the telling of a story and I like that in a writer. What I also like is when characters that I think I have a handle on surprise me, or others that I was always rooting for finally blossom.
My A Level English Lit. teacher said she was always a bit sad when she finished reading Jane Austen books, because she felt as if she was saying goodbye to a large group of friends - whilst I don't quite feel the same about Harry Potter, after reading seven books of their lives, it's easy to semi-realise them.
Lots of fun though Potter is, it's by no means perfect. "...Deathly Hallows" is consistent with the rest of the series, even down to those annoying bits of padding inbetween significant events. In some of the longer tomes, my reading has been interrupted by my brain shouting "Get on with it!" That said, the only real problem I have with this book is that the ending feels rushed - after really getting to know these characters it's a bit of a disappointment to not have certain things resolved after the closing scenes - even though it's cheesy beyond palatability, David Edding's epic Belgariad sequence gives us the chance to warm down and say "goodbye."
Never mind - this is a really good ending to a well sustained and honest series. Thank goodness it's finally over.
Thursday, August 30, 2007
Sunday, August 12, 2007
"Serve it Forth" - Mary Frances Kennedy Fisher, 1937
This brief history of gastronomy, from ancient Egypt to 1930's America, is laced with anecdotes, observations and recipes "like birds in a tree." It's absolutely fascinating, helped no end by the fact that Fisher is a brilliant writer and observer, able to vividly depict a waiter, restaurant or period of history with as much gusto as she can an intriguing dish.
Unfortunately, she is of the school of thought that English cooking is a grey, mushy, sorry state of affairs. Were I able to contact her, I'd point her in the direction of Orwell's "In Defence of English Cooking" (1945), but that's just an exaple of what a cracking read this book is - to want to actually speak to the author and say "me too!" or "I disagree, look at this." Brilliant stuff, left me salivating.
Unfortunately, she is of the school of thought that English cooking is a grey, mushy, sorry state of affairs. Were I able to contact her, I'd point her in the direction of Orwell's "In Defence of English Cooking" (1945), but that's just an exaple of what a cracking read this book is - to want to actually speak to the author and say "me too!" or "I disagree, look at this." Brilliant stuff, left me salivating.
Thursday, August 09, 2007
"The War of the Worlds" - Herbert George Wells, 1898
This classic, genre defining tale of alien invasion hasn't dated well in some places. The prose is rather stuffy, full of seemingly unnecessary details, and not all of the science stands up to scrutiny.
What makes it interesting is the way in which mankind deals with the situation visited upon him - herein, to the 21st century reader, lies the true horror, now that alien invasion is pretty passe and certainly unlikely from this solar system.
Wells' admiration of Darwinism is apparent in many sections of the book, to the extent where it would almost be unpublishable if certain phrases were included. Sometimes, Wells isn't so much apologising for the subjugation of "savages" by the "civilised" as saying the nature of each makes it inevitable.
This is a significant book, not just because of the genre it spawned, but because of the deeper themes he wrote about, often forgotten in modern versions of the story.
What makes it interesting is the way in which mankind deals with the situation visited upon him - herein, to the 21st century reader, lies the true horror, now that alien invasion is pretty passe and certainly unlikely from this solar system.
Wells' admiration of Darwinism is apparent in many sections of the book, to the extent where it would almost be unpublishable if certain phrases were included. Sometimes, Wells isn't so much apologising for the subjugation of "savages" by the "civilised" as saying the nature of each makes it inevitable.
This is a significant book, not just because of the genre it spawned, but because of the deeper themes he wrote about, often forgotten in modern versions of the story.
Wednesday, August 08, 2007
"In Cold Blood" - Truman Capote, 1965
Considered the first "non-fiction novel," "In Cold Blood" documents the mass murder of the Clutter family in 1965, the subsequent arrest the killers and the process of their trial.
The book catapulted Capote to super stardom, but detractors pointed out disrepancies with regards to fact, or rather criticised fictitious elaboration of contemporary events (that what is published as non-fiction is nothing of the sort) and the moral problem of being so close to those involved, whilst being a novelist writing a novel, rather than a journalist communicating bare facts.
In it's favour, "In Cold Blood" is an astounding piece of writing, evocative, influential and cooly detatched. It's hybrid nature is fascinating, creating a loop where real people are works of fiction, and vice versa.
The book catapulted Capote to super stardom, but detractors pointed out disrepancies with regards to fact, or rather criticised fictitious elaboration of contemporary events (that what is published as non-fiction is nothing of the sort) and the moral problem of being so close to those involved, whilst being a novelist writing a novel, rather than a journalist communicating bare facts.
In it's favour, "In Cold Blood" is an astounding piece of writing, evocative, influential and cooly detatched. It's hybrid nature is fascinating, creating a loop where real people are works of fiction, and vice versa.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
